On Moderates And Ideology

First my apologies to Chris for quoting his whole entry, but he might die some day and I don’t want to lose this one.

I should have written about this before: the contention that you have no ideology is foolishness. Everybody has an ideology even if their ideology is that they have no ideology. Why anyone would embrace a manner of thought that’s this blinkered, I have no idea. After all, an ideology is simply a set of ideas, or principles, that you use to determine your position on political issues.

Your ideology may defy labels and may be a mixture of several ideologies, but it’s there nonetheless. Even so, politicians have managed to demonize the mention of ideology and, in doing so, have lowered the national discourse. Here’s Chris:

Newsflash to Kevin (and anyone else in punditry under the misguided impression they are moderate): nobody with a well-developed political ideology is a moderate .By definition , if you are liberal, conservative, libertarian, socialist, communist, Enviro-wacko, batshit neocon, or whatever the hell Pat Buchanan and Bob Novak are (paleo-pseudo-con?), you cannot be moderate. George Bush isn’t moderate. Nor is Colin Powell, Janet Reno, Howard Dean, Glenn Reynolds, Megan McArdle, or Kevin Drum. Nor am I.

Most Americans—and most people the world over, in fact—don’t have consistent, ideological belief systems. The absence of those belief systems makes them moderate, because they just react to whatever’s going on in the political ether; if you’re lucky, you might be able to pin their beliefs to some overarching fundamental value (“hard work”, “equality”, “liberty”).

There are only two types of true moderate: people who don’t care about politics, and centrist politicians (and this latter class of people generally care less about politics than they care about keeping their jobs—I defy you to explain the behavior of Arlen Specter or Olympia Snowe otherwise). Bloggers and New York Times columnists aren’t. Anyone who cares enough about politics enough to post several essays a day explicating his or her worldview is not a moderate, and neither is anyone who’s taking time away from his academic career to publish two incoherent essays a week in America’s flagship newspaper.

Said people may be swell, wonderful, good fun at parties, open-minded, and paragons of virtue and erudition. It is not a sin to have an ideology; in fact, it is a good thing. So please don’t insult my intelligence by pretending you don’t have one.

Via dustbury.

No comments yet.

Leave a Comment